As soon as he peed in the house while i was there and on several occasions after the fact,but not hard just a firm "bad boy".Haven't done it since.I don't scold him for anything now as he waits for me to come home to take him out.
I for got to mention that when i come home,if i see him go to his bed and shaking alot,I tell him "let's go outside" and then he runs to the door and then i take him out to pee and poop.And only then he's fine with me.
Or if i give him a toy right away he will not be scared and come and play fetch. |