people ask "what do you think" about breeders all the time, i dont think it should be any different when asking abotu a member or a stranger....... why is one ok but not the other? as far as i am concerned, i didnt even know she was a member and with so many of us these days it is REALLY hard to keep track..... as long as the conversation is civil and not down right mean i dont see a problem with it (oh, and lets remember to point out the GOOD points as well as potential concerns)...... i
would ask your opinion on a potential breeder i wanted to buy from wether they were part of this forum or not, i value everyones opinion and i dont think this is any different
*by the way........ the puppies are cute

... i have only seen one ugly puppy (NO, this puppy's owner is not a member.lol..... but it was seriously the ugliest thing i have ever seen)