I forget, which Shampoo do you use again Jen? I must have 50 products under our sink. I always try everything before I start to sell it to make sure I like it for mine. I have tried the le pooch brightening shampoo now as well, and that stuff is actually amazing. Kinda pricey, but the bottle lasts for a while, and le poochs products really are wonderful! I was really surprised how much I love the happytails though. The spritzer is awesome (I dont like Ice and Ice though), and it really does make them soft