Quote:
Originally Posted by shannette barbe  the judge approached me said i cant give you first place because there is no standard for your color and handed me a second place ribbon no points nothing else was just fun for me and my dog didnt hurt anyone and didnt change anything with the standard of any yorkies or put any qualifying standards below her. we did nothing wrong no standard yorkie was beneath her |
read the reply from UKC
Dear Kimberly,
I was made aware of this today.
Yes, apparently one did compete. We do not have a show report in yet, so I can't say what the award was that the dog was given, if any.
There are no DQ's in Yorkies (in UKC or AKC) so a dog of that color couldn't be disqualified for being an off color. In order to be disqualified, there has to be a specific disqualification listed.
When I received your email I was on the phone with one of the judges from the weekend. She called me about the dog, and she said she had withheld awards, which would be the correct action, I feel, as the standard is quite specific regarding the color. Because no mention is made of the off color as a DQ, the judge should treat it as a fault and penalize the exhibit accordingly. In a standard so heavily weighted towards color, in my opinion withholding would be the best course of action.
If I can be of any more assistance, please let me know.
Mark E. Threlfall
Executive Vice President
United Kennel Club, Inc.®
Your Total Dog Registry since 1898
www.ukcdogs.com
Our Dogs do Stuff