Thanks everyone for the replies and suggestions, I really do appreciate them.
As for the declawing, I myself am not a fan of it. I had a cat declawed once and I will forever regret. He was constantly in pain and I would often find him bleeding from the knuckles.
But the clawing isn't much of the issue. Skittles hardly ever uses her claws. She has never clawed anyone before, she prefers not to use her claws. She will knead you with her paws and she does it so gently that you can't feel her nails at all. The thing I am worried about is her strength and the impact from a hit. Yes her claw caught on Scamp's eye, but that wasn't the only damage done. She also hurt his face pretty bad just from smacking him. I am lucky more damage wasn't done.
I guess you have to realize that she isn't a small weak little kitty. She is a big strong cat. She is 3 times Brownie's size and the sheer impact of her paw if she ever got him could do some serious damage.
So even if I did get her declawed, that would only solve half of the problem.
She really is the sweetest cat you will ever meet, just doesn't get along with small dogs. She is even great with big dogs just hates the small ones for some reason.
There is a rescue group in the next county over. I think I will call them and see what they say or suggest or if they have any ideas. They are a no kill sanctuary and the animals are put in foster homes instead of a shelter. But I am still going to explore all possibilities before I decide on anything.
Scamp goes in tomorrow for his checkup. His eye looks alot better, the only thing I am concerned about is the bubble that is still in his eye. The vet said to keep an eye on it and the meds should have healed it up but it is still there. But hopefully it is enough of an improvement.
Again thanks everyone for your support and help!!