My little Roxie loves the small furry animal toys they have at Petco - I know not everyone's favorite store - but they have a little pig, I think a duck and sheep and several others - they are fairly inexpensive and tiny.
But Roxie also loves her bigger toys!! Especially her squirrels! She is just 3 1/2 punds and loves her gray squirrel and her black squirrel that are a part of the American Kennel Club line - this line highlights hunting type animals. We buy the smallest ones in this line, as I think they come in several sizes. I think if you can find the rabbit, it comes in a pretty small size. You can get these a lot of places, even at Target. These are good substitutes for when Roxie can't be outside hunting for the real ones!! We need a brown toy squirrel though - because that's what she chases around the yard every day!
Also, another one of her favorites is a red fuzzy flip flop that I bought in the $1 bin at Target last year - Target also has small toys similar to the ones at Petco and often for just a buck - look in the pet aisle if you don't see something in the dollar bins.
yorkiesmiles