What a fun & creative clue Cindy! I went & checked Toby's sign up post and Toby is in the running to be Emmitt's SB but only IF your one and only hint so far is in fact real and true

AND only IF you meant just the numbers within the post and does NOT include the numbers under our user name (ie: # of posts, # of blog entries). It those numbers are included, then we're way over board.
Okay, so let's see if you can be just as creative with hint number 2.