View Single Post
Old 04-23-2010, 10:35 AM   #4
TLC
Slave to My Rug-Rats
Donating Member
 
TLC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Long Island
Posts: 7,247
Default

Other officers are paid an average of $45,000 a year, plus “a bit extra” for their participation in the television show, Mr. Riedel said. The society would not say what it is paid for “Animal Precinct,” which draws 3.5 million viewers in peak weeks.

“We immediately saw Annemarie’s potential,” said Sally Anne Lomas, a producer of the show for Anglia Television of England. “Her feistiness. The little blonde on the streets.”

Questioning a Rosy Image

Beyond the klieg lights, though, critics say “Animal Precinct” resembles other reality shows that present overly positive views of police performance.

“You get the idea from the show that they are patrolling constantly,” said Amy K. Tanguay, a credit manager for a Manhattan law firm. But when she reported several cases of abuse to the unit, she said, no one pursued them.

“Their whole attitude,” she said, “is extremely defensive: ‘We can’t do anything about it. It’s not our problem. Have a nice day.’ ”

Last year, the society’s cruelty hot line received more than 50,000 calls and determined that 4,191, fewer than a tenth of them, were bona fide complaints. Of those, officers made arrests in 103 cases, or 2.5 percent. An additional 109 people received summonses.

Police agencies typically make arrests in a higher percentage of cases, even for the tough-to-solve crimes like burglary, where officials generally push for clearance rates above 10 percent. But A.S.P.C.A. officials said cruelty cases were particularly difficult because animals cannot testify.

“It takes weeks to make these cases,” Ms. Lucas said. “Agents come back again and again on rechecks.”

Mr. Riedel said that despite the screening the society does, the cruelty complaints it receives are not as solid as the reports filed with a traditional police agency.

“If I was a detective commander and had 4,000 of them, and then I only had 103 arrests, I’d be as skeptical as you are right now,” he said. “But we are actually getting a lot of calls that are not, in fact, crimes. They are disputes, or we have to go and educate people.”

Mr. Riedel added, “If you actually look at where there are crimes where we can say an animal was intentionally neglected or maltreated, it’s much, much smaller. It’s not 4,000 to 103, it probably comes down to 300 to 103.”

It is difficult to compare animal police units because their responsibilities and jurisdictions vary. Some organizations, for example, collect stray animals, as the A.S.P.C.A. once did. But the society decided to focus on anticruelty efforts, and a city-sponsored nonprofit group took over the dog-catching function in 1995.

In Los Angeles, though, S.P.C.A. officers perform nearly identical duties, albeit on a much smaller scale, with 10 agents and an $860,000 budget. They make one arrest for about every eight cruelty investigations, versus one for every 40 in New York.

An A.S.P.C.A. spokeswoman questioned whether the comparison was fair because the two agencies are so different in size and have different jurisdictional boundaries.

Critics, however, say the A.S.P.C.A. needs to be more energetic.

Garo Alexanian, executive director of the Companion Animal Network, an 18-year-old New York City advocacy group, said the officers were not active enough in inspecting the stables used by Central Park carriage horses, or monitoring them on hot and cold days. The society, which has a dedicated officer for those efforts, denies both charges.

Patty Adjamine, the director of New Yorkers for Companion Animals, a Manhattan rescue group, said she happened to be on Lexington Avenue one day in March when a man got out of a car and began capturing pigeons with a net. Fearing he meant to use the birds for torture or target practice, she said she called the A.S.P.C.A. to provide the man’s license plate number. Her call, she said, went to voice mail at 3 in the afternoon.

“The A.S.P.C.A. never even called me back,” she said.

A.S.P.C.A. officials said they could not find a record of Ms. Adjamine’s call.

“Please note,” said a spokeswoman, Anita Kelso Edson, “that we don’t call back every person who calls us with a complaint. They’re welcome to contact us again, but we don’t have the resources to return every complaint call.”

Small Part of the Approach

The police unit, with a budget of $3.6 million, is actually one of the largest of its type in the nation and has peace officer powers under state law. In the past five years it has gained three officers, $1.8 million in financing and a new headquarters in Queens. Though no one covers the overnight shift, or answers the cruelty hot line after 6 p.m., officials said most complaints were assigned to officers within two hours.

But with cruelty on a pace to increase again this year, are 18 officers enough?

“I don’t believe they are overwhelmed,” Mr. Riedel said. “I believe that we are asking much more from them.”

The A.S.P.C.A. responds to cruelty in a variety of ways, and the Humane Law Enforcement division represents just a small part of its approach. Critics, though, say the budget shortchanges a program that is at the heart of the society’s mission.

Its Communications Department, for example, which handles advertising campaigns, operates the Web site and creates member publications, received $6.3 million in 2005, nearly twice as much as Humane Law Enforcement, according to the society’s tax return for that year, the latest available. The A.S.P.C.A. said its 2006 return was not ready yet.

The rest of the budget goes toward, among other things, financing a respected animal hospital, making grants to other groups, educating people about animal welfare, increasing pet adoptions and lowering euthanasia rates.

Stephen Musso, the society’s chief of operations, said that the organization listened to its critics but was satisfied that it had set reasonable priorities.

“We wish we were perfect,” he said. “We can’t be all things to all people.”

Claims and Counterclaims

An officer who left the agency several years ago, John Lopez, said one enforcement problem was that efforts are sometimes tailored for the show, whose crews routinely accompany officers in the field.

“If it’s not exciting, not a great case, they put it on a back burner,” he said.

Mr. Riedel denied that. “The film crew chooses what they want,” he said, adding, “We investigate all the cases, but they pick and choose.”

Last month, a judge found that an A.S.P.C.A. officer had played for the cameras in pursuing cruelty charges against two Staten Island men for neglecting their pets. The men, Kevin Lewis, 58, and Barry Leo Delaney, 68, denied the cruelty allegation and offered veterinary records, but they were arrested and some of their dogs and cats were seized at their home in October 2005.

Judge Matthew A. Sciarrino Jr. of Criminal Court ruled that the A.S.P.C.A. officer, John De La Torre, “in an effort to play the starring role,” improperly took the animals after going to the door with a camera crew shooting from the sidewalk.

The judge said that the officer did not have a warrant and that Mr. Delaney had been improperly urged to come outside his house to benefit the cameras.

“He wanted to arrest this defendant, as this would make for ‘better’ television,” said the judge, who dismissed the case.

“An officer who may behave one way with no camera present may behave differently with a television crew following him,” he wrote.

Discovery Communications, which owns “Animal Precinct,” ultimately decided not to use the segment. A spokeswoman declined to comment on the dispute.

The A.S.P.C.A. said it remained convinced its officer acted correctly. A spokesman for the Staten Island district attorney’s office said it was “reviewing our options” in the case.
__________________
Adopt Donate Foster
www.yorkie911rescue.com
TLC is offline   Reply With Quote
Welcome Guest!
Not Registered?

Join today and remove this ad!