[Crickettsmom]

I would go with number two. It is grain free, no oats. Oats are good for topical issues, but can cause some allergies if eaten. I know what the second food is and highly recommend it. It is what we are transitioning to when get close to running out of the Timeberwolf Ocean Blue. The first one has oats listed twice and you can not really tell if it actually has anymore meat than the second one. Just my opinion of course!